James Durstein Wins Federal Court Order on CME Conditions

James Durstein Wins Federal Court Order on CME Conditions

In Florida, there are multiple reasons for removing bodily injury damages cases from state court to federal court. One is that the law on getting compulsory medical examinations is more favorable to the defense in federal court.
In state court, Florida law allows plaintiffs to condition compulsory medical examinations on videographers, court reporters, and plaintiffs' attorneys being allowed to attend. In federal court, plaintiffs must show "good cause" before such outsiders are allowed to attend compulsory medical examinations.
On August 22, 2019, James Durstein won a federal court order denying a plaintiff's motion to bring his attorney or a videographer to the examination. James opposed the motion. The court ruled that "good cause" requires the plaintiff to show "a special circumstance" warranting the presence of a third party at the examination. The court ruled that, in this case, the plaintiff failed to make any such showing. If you would like a copy of the order, please call James or send him an email.


James Durstein


904-346-3166 ext 3034


Brian Guter and James Durstein frequently remove lawsuits to federal court, oppose motions to remand to state court, and litigate cases in federal court.  If you have any questions about the advantages of federal court over state court in bodily injury damages cases in northeast Florida, contact James or Brian.

Brian Guter


904-346-3166 ext 3026


  • Bad faith and extra-contractual damages
  • Commercial disputes
  • Construction disputes and defects
  • False claims
  • Insurance fraud
  • Insurance and coverage issues
  • Motor vehicle accidents
  • Negligence claims
  • Premises liability
  • Products liability
  • Professional liability
  • SIU investigations


The Florida Bar regulates advertising by lawyers, and may consider lawyers’ websites a form of advertising. 

  • The hiring of a lawyer is an important decision that should not be based solely upon advertisements.
  • The material on this web site is informational only. We give no legal advice on this web site.
  • Results may not be typical. You may not have as beneficial a result.



Directed Defense Verdict

January 13, 2010

On January 13th, 2010, Deborah Halvorsen and Amy McGuiness obtained a…

Read More

Directed Defense Verdict

January 3, 2010

On January 13th, 2010, Deborah Halvorsen and Amy McGuiness obtained a…

Read More

Defense Verdict

March 24, 2009

In March 26, 2009, Deborah Halvorsen obtained a directed verdict in…

Read More


O’Hara Law Firm, P.A.



4811 Beach Boulevard, Suite 303
Jacksonville, FL  32207


Leave a Comment