James Durstein and Mike Regan Win in Duval County
During the second week in August 2019, after four days of jury trial, James Durstein and Mike Regan prevailed with a favorable jury verdict in a motor vehicle accident case. The plaintiff's attorneys told the jury from the beginning of the trial that they would be asking for millions of dollars based in large part on future interventional pain management expense. But, before letting the case go to the jury, the court directed a verdict in our client's favor on all future medical expense other than physical therapy.
It became clear on our cross-examination of the plaintiff's pain management physician that the claim of future pain management expense was speculative. Consequently, the court would not allow the plaintiff's life care planning expert to express opinions regarding future pain management expense.
Despite the directed verdict on future medical expense, Plaintiff's attorneys asked the jury to award her over $4 million for past and future pain and suffering. We conceded that the plaintiff sustained cervical and lumbar strains, but argued that she did not suffer a permanent injury.
We suggested that the jury's award of past medical expense be limited to $13,800 for the initial emergency department visit and for the first 2 1/2 months of chiropractic treatment. This is exactly what the jury awarded. The jury also found that the plaintiff did not sustain a permanent injury, so the jury did not award any damages for pain and suffering.
This was a defense verdict.
AREAS OF PRACTICE
- Bad faith and extra-contractual damages
- Commercial disputes
- Construction disputes and defects
- False claims
- Insurance fraud
- Insurance and coverage issues
- Motor vehicle accidents
- Negligence claims
- Premises liability
- Products liability
- Professional liability
- SIU investigations
The Florida Bar regulates advertising by lawyers, and may consider lawyers’ websites a form of advertising.
- The hiring of a lawyer is an important decision that should not be based solely upon advertisements.
- The material on this web site is informational only. We give no legal advice on this web site.
- Results may not be typical. You may not have as beneficial a result.
In March 2016, after a five-day jury trial in which the…Read More
This is another good reason to remove lawsuits for UM benefits from state court to federal court where such is possible.Read More
The dangerous instrumentality doctrine is unique to the State of Florida.Read More
Steve O’Hara recently won orders from the trial court denying a plaintiff’s motions for new trial and to set aside a defense verdict.Read More