Michael Regan and Brian Guter Win No-Permanency Verdict in April 2018 UM Case

On April 13, 2018, a jury returned a favorable verdict for an insurance company which was represented by Michael Regan and Brian Guter in a lawsuit for uninsured motorist benefits.
The plaintiff was a female teacher who was in her mid-30s with no prior history of treatment for neck or back complaints.  She claimed that she sustained permanent neck and back injuries, including an annular tear with disc bulges in her cervical spine and an annular tear with disc bulges and a disc herniation in her lumbar spine as a result of an accident which occurred in front of a local high school.
Liability, causation, permanency, and damages were contested.  Brian handled the liability witnesses and Mike handled the medical witnesses.
At trial, the plaintiff’s attorney asked the jury to award past medical expenses of $18,508.80 and future medical expenses amounting to $197,501.00 based on testimony of plaintiff’s treating pain management physician.  He asked the jury to find that plaintiff was permanently injured and to award her $39,960.00 for past pain and suffering and $992,947.00 for future pain and suffering for total damages amounting to $1,248,915.84.
During closing arguments, Mike argued for apportionment of negligence and asked the jury to award a portion of Plaintiff’s past medical expenses, but nothing else.  The jury apportioned 30% of the negligence to the plaintiff.  The jury awarded all of her past medical expenses and $20,000.00 for future medical expenses.  The jury found that she did not sustain a permanent injury and, therefore, did not award her any non-economic losses, past or future.


  • Bad faith and extra-contractual damages
  • Commercial disputes
  • Construction disputes and defects
  • False claims
  • Insurance fraud
  • Insurance and coverage issues
  • Motor vehicle accidents
  • Negligence claims
  • Premises liability
  • Products liability
  • Professional liability
  • SIU investigations


The Florida Bar regulates advertising by lawyers, and may consider lawyers’ websites a form of advertising. 

  • The hiring of a lawyer is an important decision that should not be based solely upon advertisements.
  • The material on this web site is informational only. We give no legal advice on this web site.
  • Results may not be typical. You may not have as beneficial a result.



Invitation to Join Claims and Litigation Management Alliance (CLM)

February 13, 2013

O’Hara Halvorsen Humphries, PA is pleased to announce that J. Stephen…

Read More

Keeping Up To Date

January 28, 2013

On January 24, 2013, Steve and Jeri O’Hara attended the “Bad…

Read More

Order Denying Motion to Remand

January 11, 2013

On January 9, 2013, a federal trial court entered an order…

Read More

Rare Win for Insurance Company

December 18, 2012

Jeff Humphries obtained an exceptional verdict for an insurance company in…

Read More

JADC Vice President

December 13, 2012

Congratulations to attorney Aurora Vaca who was nominated for, and accepted…

Read More

Favorable Verdict for Defense (brain-injured child)

December 10, 2012

Steve and Jeri O’Hara won a favorable verdict for the defense…

Read More

Trial Featured in DRI Newsletter

December 7, 2012

An exceptional defense verdict achieved by the firm on behalf of…

Read More

Another Win on Appeal

December 6, 2012

On December 3, 2012, the Florida First District Court of Appeal…

Read More

Three Attorneys Named Among Jacksonville’s Best

November 14, 2012

Three of our attorneys were recently included among “Jacksonville’s Top Lawyers”…

Read More

Favorable Appellate Decision

August 3, 2012

In August 2012, Susan was successful in having our defense verdict…

Read More


O’Hara Law Firm, P.A.



4811 Beach Boulevard, Suite 303
Jacksonville, FL  32207


Leave a Comment